Brewdog, the renowned Scottish brewery, has been forced to dispose of millions of pounds worth of its flagship beer, Punk IPA, following a “major quality incident” that led to contamination. The incident, which took place at the company’s Ellon brewery in Aberdeenshire, resulted in a significant loss of beer and widespread customer complaints.
Contamination and Financial Impact
Chris Fielden, Brewdog’s Chief Supply Chain Officer, revealed the extent of the problem in an internal email, condemning the breach of hygiene protocols within the brewing process. The contamination, referred to as “sour beer,” led to millions of pounds worth of product being discarded, severely impacting the company’s operations. Fielden noted that the brewery missed its August productivity target by £950,000, although the total losses are believed to be much higher.
Some contaminated beer was sent to customers, which led to the highest rate of customer complaints in the company’s history. The contaminated batches not only affected the company’s revenue but also damaged its reputation for producing high-quality craft beer.
Internal Response and Accountability
In his email, Fielden expressed frustration over the root cause of the contamination, pointing to poor hygiene practices within the brewing operations. He highlighted the lack of personal accountability among staff, stating that employees had been shifting blame instead of addressing the hygiene issues directly. “Shop floor hygiene is the responsibility of every single one of us,” Fielden stressed in his email.
Fielden also detailed how the contamination and subsequent beer wastage had significantly affected Brewdog’s earnings, noting the direct impact on the company’s EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization).
Industry Perspective
Beer industry expert Melissa Cole commented on the incident, acknowledging that contamination can happen in beer production. However, she criticized the tone of Fielden’s email, suggesting that the company should take a more constructive approach. “The wording of the email seems very demoralizing for staff,” Cole said, adding that Brewdog has a history of blaming employees rather than offering support to resolve issues.
Brewdog’s Response to Customers
Brewdog has since taken steps to manage the fallout from the contamination. A company spokesperson downplayed the scale of the incident, stating that the affected beer represented only 0.02% of their annual production. They assured customers that the sour-tasting beer posed no health risks and offered refunds to those who complained.
“Beer quality is our absolute number one priority,” the spokesperson said. “While most of the affected beer did not leave the brewery, a small quantity reached some of our customers. The cause of the issue was quickly identified and resolved, and any customer who raised concerns with us was compensated.”
Leadership Changes and Controversies
The contamination issue comes during a period of significant change for Brewdog. In May, the company’s co-founder and former CEO, James Watt, stepped down after 17 years at the helm. Watt, who remains a director and strategic advisor to the leadership team, has faced numerous controversies during his tenure, including allegations of creating a “culture of fear” within the company. Despite his resignation, Watt continues to play a significant role in the business.
Watt’s partner, reality TV star Georgia Toffolo, expressed her support for him when he stepped down, stating that she was proud of his decision.
Moving Forward
Despite the heavy financial and reputational damage caused by the contamination, Brewdog remains focused on maintaining its position as a leading craft beer producer. The company has not disclosed specific details regarding the volume of wasted beer or the exact number of customer complaints, but it has reaffirmed its commitment to quality and accountability.
Chris Fielden, who was appointed Chief Supply Chain Officer in May 2023, is tasked with ensuring such incidents do not occur in the future. He brings experience from previous roles at Warp Snacks and Innocent Drinks.
As Brewdog navigates this challenging period, the company is working to rebuild trust with its customers and prevent similar issues from disrupting its production.
You Might Be Interested In:
- How Long It Takes to Make Homemade Beer? A Comprehensive Guide
- Is Tequiza Beer Still Made?
- How is Modern Beer Made? 5 Efficient Steps
