The availability of imported organic wine in the U.S. may soon be jeopardized due to a contentious new regulation imposed by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). Effective last year, the USDA has mandated that, in addition to vineyard and winery certification, wine importers must also obtain organic certification to label their products as organic. Critics argue this requirement is unnecessary and burdensome, as importers do not handle the wine itself.
As importers scramble to meet this new requirement, a backlog of applications has emerged, leaving many uncertified ahead of the compliance deadline. Currently, over 1,800 “handling operations” in the U.S. are certified, but the slow processing of applications by the USDA has created significant uncertainty for importers. Failure to comply could result in severe financial penalties and legal repercussions for those involved in the organic wine trade.
A USDA spokesperson confirmed that violations could lead to “significant monetary penalties” and highlighted that the agency collaborates with the Department of Justice on cases deemed high-impact. The implications are alarming, especially as a potential dockworker strike on the East Coast looms, which could further delay the importation of organic wines.
Congressman Nick Langworthy, representing New York’s Finger Lakes region, has taken action by requesting a 120-day extension for importers to secure certification. This letter, supported by bipartisan members of the House Committee on Agriculture, emphasizes the unreasonable burden placed on importers by this regulation. Langworthy pointed out that the rule was not enacted by Congress but rather originated from bureaucratic decisions.
The USDA has stated that its rationale for requiring importers to be certified is to prevent fraud and ensure accountability within the organic food system. However, critics argue that the existing paperwork already provides traceability for shipments and that this new rule unfairly complicates the process for organic wine importers.
The Wine and Spirits Wholesalers of America (WSWA), a key player in the wine industry, has expressed serious concerns regarding the operational disruptions caused by these regulations. They argue that many importers previously exempt from certification now face significant delays, threatening their business and the integrity of the international wine market.
As the debate continues, the hope for reform remains, with advocates urging the USDA to reconsider or repeal the new regulations altogether, asserting that the current framework serves only to complicate the importation of organic wines without offering any tangible benefits.
You Might Be Interested In:
- What Sparkling Wine is Good for Mimosas?
- Is Sparkling Wine the Same as Prosecco?
- What Can You Mix With Sparkling Wine?
