Mezcal and tequila are two of Mexico’s most famous distilled spirits. Both are made from agave, a plant native to the region, but they differ significantly in terms of production processes, flavors, and health implications. In recent years, mezcal has seen a surge in popularity, often touted as a healthier alternative to tequila. But is this really true?
This article will explore the key factors that differentiate mezcal and tequila, with a particular focus on their health benefits and drawbacks. By the end, you will have a clearer understanding of which drink may be the better choice for you, whether you’re looking for a cleaner, more natural option or simply want to enjoy a delicious and unique beverage.
What is Mezcal?
A Brief History of Mezcal
Mezcal is an ancient Mexican spirit that dates back to pre-Hispanic times. The Aztecs and other indigenous peoples of Mexico created fermented beverages from agave, but it wasn’t until the Spanish introduced distillation techniques in the 16th century that mezcal as we know it today began to take shape. Mezcal is made from the agave plant, but unlike tequila, it can be crafted from any type of agave.
The Production Process
The production of mezcal is more traditional and often more artisanal than tequila. After harvesting the agave plant, the heart (or piña) is roasted in an underground pit, giving mezcal its signature smoky flavor. The roasted agave is then fermented and distilled, with the process typically involving smaller batches and more manual labor.
Types of Mezcal
Mezcal can vary greatly in terms of flavor and quality. Some of the most common types of agave used to make mezcal include Espadín, Tobala, and Madrecuixe. The choice of agave has a significant impact on the taste and complexity of the final product.
What is Tequila?
A Brief History of Tequila
Tequila, like mezcal, is a distilled spirit made from the agave plant. However, its production is more regulated. Tequila must be made specifically from blue agave, a variety of agave that is grown in certain regions of Mexico, primarily in Jalisco. The drink has a long history, originating in the 16th century, and was first produced by the indigenous people of Mexico.
The Production Process
Tequila production is less smoky compared to mezcal. The agave hearts are steamed in ovens or autoclaves, a method that is much cleaner than roasting. After this, the agave is shredded, fermented, and distilled to create the final product. The production process for tequila is more mechanized, with larger factories and higher production volumes.
Types of Tequila
Tequila comes in several varieties, including Blanco (unaged), Reposado (aged for 2-12 months), and Añejo (aged for at least one year). The aging process affects the flavor of the tequila, with older tequilas often being smoother and more complex.
How Do Mezcal and Tequila Differ in Terms of Health?
The Role of Agave
Both mezcal and tequila are made from agave, but the type of agave used can affect their nutritional profile. Mezcal is made from a wider variety of agave species, many of which have higher concentrations of certain compounds believed to have health benefits. Some studies suggest that the different agave species used in mezcal may contain more antioxidants and other beneficial compounds compared to the blue agave used in tequila.
However, the health differences between the two spirits are relatively minimal when considering just the agave plant itself. Both drinks are considered “cleaner” than many other distilled spirits because they come from a natural plant source.
Alcohol Content
Both mezcal and tequila typically have an alcohol content of around 40% ABV (alcohol by volume), though this can vary depending on the brand and specific type. The alcohol content of the two drinks is very similar, which means that their effects on the body are largely the same. In other words, drinking too much of either can have negative health consequences, including dehydration, hangovers, and liver damage.
Calories and Sugar
When comparing mezcal and tequila in terms of calories, the difference is minimal. Both drinks contain approximately 65-70 calories per ounce. Neither spirit contains added sugars, which is one of the reasons both are considered “cleaner” than many other alcoholic beverages. However, flavored mezcals or tequilas may have additional sugars or artificial ingredients, which can increase their calorie content.
The health benefits of both drinks are generally related to their lack of added sugars and low calorie content, especially when compared to sweetened liqueurs or cocktails that may contain syrups or artificial flavorings.
The Potential Health Benefits of Mezcal and Tequila
Antioxidants and Other Beneficial Compounds
Mezcal, particularly those made from wild agave species, is often praised for its high antioxidant content. Antioxidants are compounds that can help fight free radicals in the body, potentially reducing oxidative stress and the risk of chronic diseases such as heart disease and cancer. While the scientific evidence surrounding the health benefits of mezcal’s antioxidants is still limited, it is often marketed as a “healthier” option because of its more natural production methods.
Tequila, on the other hand, has some health benefits that have been more widely studied. One key benefit is that tequila, particularly 100% blue agave tequila, is low in fructans, which are compounds that can cause digestive issues for some individuals. Since tequila is made from the blue agave, which has a lower fructan content than other agave varieties, it is considered easier on the digestive system than some other alcoholic beverages.
The Low Glycemic Index
Tequila has a lower glycemic index (GI) than many other alcoholic drinks. The GI measures how quickly a food or drink raises blood sugar levels. Because tequila is made from blue agave, which contains certain sugars (called agavins) that do not spike blood sugar levels, it is considered a better option for people with diabetes or those trying to maintain stable blood sugar levels. However, it is important to note that moderation is key, as excessive alcohol consumption can still disrupt blood sugar regulation.
Mezcal, on the other hand, is made from a broader range of agave varieties, some of which may have different glycemic properties. However, more research is needed to fully understand the glycemic effects of mezcal.
The Role of Agavins
Agavins are a type of sugar found in the agave plant, and they are considered to be beneficial because they do not contribute to raising blood sugar levels. Agavins are non-digestible and can act as a prebiotic, promoting the growth of healthy gut bacteria. Tequila made from 100% blue agave contains agavins, making it a potentially better choice for those looking to support their digestive health.
Mezcal made from other types of agave may also contain agavins, although the concentration may vary depending on the type of agave used. As with tequila, the health benefits of agavins in mezcal are still being studied.
The Potential Drawbacks of Mezcal and Tequila
Overconsumption and Health Risks
As with any alcoholic beverage, excessive consumption of mezcal or tequila can have serious health consequences. Drinking large amounts of alcohol, regardless of the type, can lead to liver damage, heart disease, and other chronic health conditions. Additionally, both mezcal and tequila can be high in congeners—chemicals produced during fermentation—that are known to contribute to hangovers.
Mezcal is often consumed in smaller amounts due to its stronger and more smoky flavor, but this does not mean it is any less harmful when consumed in large quantities. Similarly, while tequila is typically consumed in larger quantities during cocktails or shots, overconsumption can also have significant health risks.
The Impact on Gut Health
While both mezcal and tequila have the potential to aid in digestion due to their lower fructan content, alcohol in general can disrupt gut health when consumed in large amounts. Over time, heavy drinking can lead to gut microbiota imbalance, which can affect overall health, including immune function and mental health. Moderation is key to preventing these adverse effects.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while there are some differences in the health profiles of mezcal and tequila, neither is significantly healthier than the other. Both spirits offer some potential health benefits, including antioxidants, low glycemic index properties, and gut-friendly agavins, but these benefits are largely outweighed by the risks of excessive alcohol consumption.
Ultimately, the choice between mezcal and tequila comes down to personal preference. If you prefer a smokier, more artisanal drink, mezcal might be the better choice. If you’re looking for a smoother, more widely available option, tequila made from 100% blue agave might be the better fit. Either way, moderation is key to ensuring that you enjoy these spirits without negatively impacting your health.
You Might Be Interested In:
