Italy continues to dominate the global wine scene, and this year’s list of the most coveted Italian wines is a testament to the country’s rich winemaking tradition. Leading the charge are a selection of Super Tuscans, Sangiovese blends, and Nebbiolo wines—each with its own distinctive character and impressive pedigree.
The Most Wanted Wines: Super Tuscans and Iconic Italian Reds
When it comes to the world’s most sought-after Italian wines, 2025 shows a clear preference for the deep reds of Tuscany and Piedmont. The wines on this list are consistently awarded high marks by critics, with each vintage aggregated for an overall score. It’s important to note that the ratings are weighted, with top critics lending their opinions more heavily, ensuring that only the most reliable scores make the final cut. Additionally, the prices are listed as the global average retail price (GARP) in US dollars, which may fluctuate over time.
Among the standout wines, the following are especially noteworthy:
Tenuta San Guido Sassicaia Bolgheri – Tuscany
- Price: HK$2,818 ($322)
- Score: 95/100
This iconic Super Tuscan, originally crafted in the 1940s by Marchese Mario Incisa della Rocchetta, has evolved into one of Italy’s premier wines. With its first commercial release in 1968, Sassicaia now stands as a global leader in Bordeaux-style Italian reds. The wine has experienced steady price increases over the past decade, from $214 to $322, reflecting its growing reputation.
Marchesi Antinori Tignanello Toscana IGT – Tuscany
- Price: HK$1,483 ($189)
- Score: 94/100
Produced by one of Italy’s most esteemed estates, Tignanello is a blend of Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Cabernet Franc. Antinori’s ongoing innovation has made Tignanello a symbol of Tuscan winemaking, with its score rising from 93 ten years ago to 94 today. Over the same period, its price has almost doubled from $93 to $189.
Ornellaia Bolgheri Superiore – Tuscany
- Price: HK$2,072 ($267)
- Score: 95/100
From the heart of Tuscany’s Bolgheri region, Ornellaia is a powerhouse blend, primarily dominated by Cabernet Sauvignon, and has been lauded for its consistency and elegance. The wine, which has enjoyed steady acclaim since its first vintage in 1985, has increased in price from $187 a decade ago.
Masseto Toscana IGT – Tuscany
- Price: HK$7,629 ($983)
- Score: 96/100
Another gem from the Frescobaldi family, Masseto is produced entirely from Merlot and has become a symbol of luxury in the world of Italian wine. Known for its rich fruit and complexity, Masseto has garnered a perfect score of 96 points. However, its steep price tag—rising from $648 a decade ago—places it firmly in the premium category.
Marchesi Antinori Solaia Toscana IGT – Tuscany
- Price: HK$2,955 ($381)
- Score: 95/100
Solaia, often considered Antinori’s flagship wine, is a blend of Sangiovese and Cabernet Sauvignon. It has been a favorite among critics, earning consistent high ratings over the years, and its price has steadily risen from $224 ten years ago.
Nebbiolo’s Rise: Piedmont’s Standout Wines
While Tuscany dominates the list, Piedmont’s Nebbiolo-based wines make their mark with two exceptional entries:
Giacomo Conterno Monfortino Riserva DOCG – Barolo, Piedmont
- Price: HK$10,525 ($1,352)
- Score: 96/100
Giacomo Conterno’s Monfortino is the epitome of Barolo, with a winemaking history that dates back to 1908. The wine, made only in the best vintages and aged for seven years, has a legendary reputation. It commands the highest price on this list—nearly $1,400—yet its score reflects its quality and rarity, with a steep increase from $643 ten years ago.
Gaja Barbaresco DOCG – Barbaresco, Piedmont
- Price: HK$2,160 ($278)
- Score: 93/100
Gaja, one of the most renowned names in Italian winemaking, has elevated Nebbiolo-based Barbaresco to international acclaim. While not as expensive as some of the other wines on this list, it remains a highly regarded expression of Nebbiolo, with its price rising from $176 ten years ago.
Tuscan Classics: The Best of Brunello and Sangiovese
Rounding out the list are a few classic Tuscan wines, including some of the best Brunello di Montalcino and Sangiovese-based offerings:
Biondi Santi Tenuta Greppo Brunello di Montalcino DOCG – Tuscany
- Price: HK$1,738 ($224)
- Score: 94/100
Often credited with founding the Brunello di Montalcino appellation, Biondi Santi’s Tenuta Greppo is one of the most revered wines in Italy. Its consistent quality and dedication to the Sangiovese grape have earned it a solid score of 94, though its price has nearly doubled over the past decade.
Montevertine Le Pergole Torte Toscana IGT – Tuscany
- Price: HK$2,464 ($316)
- Score: 95/100
Known for its pure Sangiovese expression, Montevertine’s Le Pergole Torte has developed a cult following since its inception. Its score of 95 points reflects its pedigree, though its price has surged from $109 ten years ago to $316 today.
Conclusion
Despite the dominance of red wines, there is a noticeable diversity in the styles, blends, and regions represented in the top wines of 2025. Tuscany’s Super Tuscans continue to be a favorite, but Piedmont’s Nebbiolos have carved out their place as well, with prices ranging from relatively accessible to stratospheric. The overall price spectrum—from $171 for a bottle of Fontodi Flaccianello to $1,352 for Giacomo Conterno Monfortino—shows that there is something for every palate and budget, as long as you have a preference for red.
The evolving wine market reflects an enduring passion for quality, tradition, and innovation in Italian winemaking, making 2025 a thrilling year for wine enthusiasts.
Related topics:
- Does White Zinfandel Need to Be Chilled?
- How Many Calories Are in White Zinfandel?
- How Much Sugar is in Sutter Home White Zinfandel?
